Author
Devin DaRif
Share:
The question that actually drives career decisions isn't the one companies spend their time answering.
Companies answer "what do we offer." Competitive compensation, strong benefits, growth opportunities, flexible work arrangements. These things matter. They get you into the consideration set. But they don't determine the outcome. Candidates who are seriously considering multiple options have already filtered for the basics. The spreadsheet comparison happens after the gut decision is mostly made.
People stay in difficult situations because the identity the job provides still feels worth it.
The Identity Question
The real question is about identity. Every job offers a version of yourself. The company you work for becomes part of how you describe yourself to others, part of how you think about who you are. Candidates are trying to figure out whether the person they'd become by taking this job is someone they want to be.
This explains behavior that looks irrational from the outside. People take pay cuts to work somewhere that feels more "them." People leave jobs that look great on paper because something about being there makes them feel like a diminished version of themselves. People stay in difficult situations because the identity the job provides still feels worth it.
When someone accepts an offer, they're choosing a story they'll tell about themselves for the next chapter of their career. When they leave, it's rarely about money, despite what exit interviews suggest. The story stopped working. The mirror started reflecting back someone they didn't recognize or didn't want to be.
If everyone who reads it thinks "that sounds great," you haven't said anything.
The Filter Is the Feature
Specificity is what makes identity work as a filter. A strong employer brand should turn some people off. If everyone who reads it thinks "that sounds great," you haven't said anything. You want people to self-select, to recognize either that this is their place or that it isn't. The ones who opt out would have been bad fits anyway. Better to lose them before they start than after a failed onboarding.
This reframes the entire employer brand exercise. Stop asking how to attract more candidates. Start asking what kind of person thrives here, what's true about this place that makes it right for them, and how to make that visible to the people who need to see it. The identity question comes first. The marketing follows.
More Insights
& Ideas
5 minute read
Value Strategy: From Criticism to Creation
2 minute read